Elizabeth Royte has an excellent post on pollutants in drinking water - most recently, the herbicide atrazine - and the boost it may provide to the bottled water industry. She is not arguing that we turn off the tap and head for the Fiji or whatever, but this does pose a dilemma for those of us concerned with the increasing number of chemicals found in our drinking water: what do we drink?
As she eloquently indicates, bottled water is expensive, even if we discount its environmental footprint (which we should not). What about tap filters? Those can work, but remember they don't destroy the chemicals, but just remove it from the water. Filters actually concentrate the stuff, and require proper disposal of the spent filtration medium (usually pulverized carbon). Filter users may just be transferring the problem elsewhere or 'recycling' the pollutant.
[Here is an article by Danielle Ivory about water utilities' lack of filters for atrazine - thanks to Dorian Roffe-Hammond for sending this along.]
What concerns me about all this is that we may lose the political will to maintain our municipal drinking water systems and the surface watersheds and aquifers that provide the water. That could occur if more and more people decide to forego tap water altogether and drink bottled water. If that's the case, then more than our drinking water will suffer.
If we do lose the will to maintain municipal water systems, then we will have come full circle. In the USA, starting around 100 or so years ago, one of the cogent arguments for constructing municipal drinking water systems was that they would improve health by providing clean, safe drinking water. Business leaders bought into the idea because they were convinced workers would lose fewer days to sickness, thereby increasing productivity and profits. Later on came wastewater treatment. It all worked - diseases like cholera and typhoid have all but disappeared from the USA.
Will the water make us sick again?
A slight digression: I once heard a person say that if you had to thank one profession for doing the most to improve our health, don't thank the medical profession, but the engineering profession. They built water and wastewater treatment facilities. There's quite a bit of truth to that.
As for 20-20 hindsight, I wish I'd paid more attention in Chem 201-202 (organic chemistry) in 1967-68 (you were right, Dr. Hill!), although in some ways, I'm glad I didn't. Ignorance may be bliss, but unfortunately, what you don't know can hurt you.
"The road to disaster is paved with assumptions." -- Unknown
Recent Comments