Sharon B. Megdal sent me this article, which is an open-access article from The Foundation Review, Volume 14, Issue 2 (June 2022).The issue focuses on
Philanthropy's Response to the Crises of 2020.
Recommended citation:
Petersen, N., Chief, K., Massaro, T. M., Tulley, N., Tulley-Cordova, C., & Vold, J. (2022). Respectful Tribal Partnership: What Philanthropy Can Learn From the Navajo Nation’s Collaborative Response to the COVID-19 Crisis. The Foundation Review, 14(2). https://doi.org/10.9707/1944-5660.1611
Here is the PDF:
Download Respectful Tribal Partnership_ What Philanthropy Can Learn From
I will provide enough material to whet your appetite.
Respectful Tribal Partnership: What Philanthropy Can Learn From the Navajo Nation’s Collaborative Response to the COVID-19 Crisis.
Nancy Petersen, M.S., Karletta Chief, Ph.D., Toni M. Massaro, J.D., and Nikki Tulley, M.S., University of Arizona; Crystal Tulley-Cordova, Ph.D., Navajo Nation Department of Water Resources, and Jonelle Vold, J.D., University of Arizona Foundation
Introduction The gravity of the COVID-19 pandemic and its disparately harsh impact on Indigenous peoples, including the stark reality of a historical lack of access to essential services and health care, are now well known. COVID-19 death rates, aggre- gated through May 4, 2022, and normalized by population, show there have been far more Native American than white American deaths: 454 per 100,000 versus 327 per 100,000, respec- tively (APM Research Lab, 2022). Many funders have seen the shocking realities, and responded to the crisis with new grant calls focused on Native Americans and administered through less cumbersome grant procedures. They realize that many Native American and Indigenous communities face numerous barriers to accessing basic human services, such as ready access to clean water, that most of the developed world take for granted. This desire to act is laudable. But in the zeal to immediately “fix the problems,” our Native American co-authors note, many funders fail to grasp the complexities and necessity of applying trust-based collabora- tive principles that respect tribes as sovereign nations with laws and norms that govern their lands and people. This article describes a successful model for collaboration among a tribal nation, funders, and subject matter experts to address a critical problem — in this case, access to clean water for Navajo families. The collaboration was based on respecting the leadership and values of theNavajo Nation and born from the pandemic crisis taking place there. Collaborating partners were drawn from dozens of state and federal agencies, along with nonprofits, universities, and philanthropies. All were connected by honor and respect for the Diné — “The People,” as the Navajo call themselves. This model is one that can be replicated by funders working with multiple experts, agencies, and governments elsewhere, as well as for future water sustainability projects on the Navajo Nation.
Let's skip ahead:
Key Points
• The gravity of the COVID-19 pandemic and its disparately harsh impact on Indigenous peoples are now well known. U.S. death rates normalized by population, for example, have been far higher for Native Americans than for the white population in the United States. Many funders, realizing that basic human services are lacking for many Native American and Indigenous communities, have responded to the crisis. While this desire to act is laudable, many fail to grasp the complexities and necessity of applying trust-based collaborative principles that respect tribes as sovereign nations.• This article describes a successful model for collaboration among a tribal nation, funders, and subject-matter experts to address a critical problem — access to clean water for Navajo families — based on respecting the leadership and values of the Navajo Nation and born from the pandemic crisis taking place there. Collaborating partners were drawn from dozens of state and federal agencies, nonprofits, universities, and philanthropies. All were connected by honor and respect for the Diné — “The People,” as the Navajo call themselves.
• This model can be replicated by funders working with multiple experts, agencies, and governments to continue to meet community resilience challenges that do not retreat with the pandemic and to promote equity and justice in any philanthropic venture.
Enjoy!
"You cannot see the future with tears un your eyes." - Navajo saying.
Recent Comments